Type to search

Church Investigations

Southern Baptist Pastor: Minister Accused of Abusing a Dozen Boys Never Investigated

A Georgia pastor has identified up to 13 boys he says were sexually abused by a Southern Baptist minister whom top leaders of the denomination in effect cleared two years ago when they declined to investigate the church where the minister was working.

Troy Bush, the pastor of Rehoboth Baptist in Tucker, Georgia, said he undertook his own investigation of the minister, a former staffer at Rehoboth Baptist, after learning that the Southern Baptist Convention’s Executive Committee working group would not investigate Trinity Baptist Church in Ashburn, in the southern part of the state, or six other churches suspected of harboring sex abusers. 

The minister has never been criminally charged. But Bush said the minister confessed to him and others that he abused several boys during his tenure at half a dozen Baptist churches in Georgia.

“I think the way this was handled was poor and potentially disastrous as it protected and allowed this person to remain in a pastoral ministry role in one of our churches,” said Bush, referring to the work group’s decision not to investigate.

Bush penned a June 14 article in “SBC Voices,” an independent Southern Baptist blog, detailing his findings. 

The specter of sex abuse is again on the agenda of the Southern Baptist Convention meeting Tuesday and Wednesday (June 15 and 16) in Nashville, Tennessee, in the wake of explosive allegations that top echelons of the denomination mishandled several sex abuse claims, bullied sex abuse survivors and rushed to end investigations of churches where sex abusers were alleged to work.

Access to MinistryWatch content is free.  However, we hope you will support our work with your prayers and financial gifts.  To make a donation, click here.

Several pastors and sex abuse victims are now calling for a broader inquiry into the 14 million-member denomination’s handling of sexual abuse allegations.

“It’s just like the Catholic Church or the Boy Scouts: Kick the can down the road,” said Dave Pittman, 53, who alleges he was sexually abused by the minister from 1982 to 1985 when he was a boy at Rehoboth Baptist Church. “It’s still the truth.”

Pittman’s story was detailed in the Houston Chronicle’s 2019 “Abuse of Faith” investigation, which found some 700 people had been sexually abused in Southern Baptist churches. Pittman never pressed charges against his abuser because the statute of limitations in Georgia had expired.

That series of stories led Southern Baptist Convention President J.D. Greear to identify 10 churches where, he believed, the denomination needed to determine if they have employed sex abusers or allowed them to volunteer with children. A week later, an Executive Committee work group declined to investigate seven of those churches, including Trinity Baptist. 

Bush then set about to find the truth about the minister from Trinity. With the help of Pittman, who was once a member of his church, he identified 10 boys, now men, who acknowledged being abused by the minister who has since left Trinity. Bush said he received credible, but as yet unconfirmed, reports of two additional men the minister is alleged to have abused at Georgia Baptist churches and a 13th who was not a church member. 

Members of the Executive Committee work group, including Mike Stone, who was defeated Tuesday in his bid for the SBC presidency, have said they did not have the power to conduct investigations into the churches that were dropped from Greear’s list. 

Bush said they acted too soon.

“Those engaging this inquiry should have done, at a minimum, a sufficient level of information gathering,” he added. “In the case with Trinity, that did not happen.”

Yonat Shimron

Yonat Shimron is a North Carolina-based reporter who has written about religion for more than 17 years. She is a national reporter and senior editor for Religion News Service.