Scottish Venue That Canceled 2020 Franklin Graham Event to Pay Over $100K for Violating UK Equality Act
On Monday (October 24), a Scottish court ruled in favor of the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association (BGEA) in a lawsuit against Scottish Event Campus Limited (SEC), which canceled an evangelistic event at the Hydro Arena in Glasgow featuring Franklin Graham in 2020 on the grounds of Graham’s stated beliefs about human sexuality and Islam.
Sheriff John N. McCormick ruled that SEC would be obligated to pay over $111,000 (£97,000) for violating the UK’s Equality Act.
SEC was one of seven UK venues that canceled BGEA events, part of Graham’s “God Loves You” tour, in January 2020 after facing pressure from LGBTQ+ advocates. Multiple groups argued that Graham’s public remarks regarding LGBTQ+ issues and the Muslim faith constituted dangerous hate speech.
Graham, who is the son of legendary evangelist Billy Graham and president of BGEA, has often publicly rebuked LGBTQ+ values and has referred to the Muslim faith as “wicked and evil.”
In his Monday ruling, McCormick wrote, “Briefly put, if it is correct that the event was evangelistic, based on religion or philosophical belief, then it follows that the decision to cancel was a breach of the Equality Act 2010 in that the event was cancelled as a commercial response to the views of objectors.”
McCormick ruled that SEC had discriminated against BGEA “on the basis of a protected characteristic” and would be required to pay $111,503.19 (£97,325.32) in damages.
Though SEC argued in the case that the cancellation of the event came in light of concerns regarding protests and security, McCormick ruled that these concerns were not the sole reason for the cancellation. While SEC’s board did discuss security concerns, they never raised these concerns when meeting with Glasgow City Council.
“I heard no evidence to suggest that Franklin Graham had intended to pursue a toxic or dangerous agenda at the event. On the contrary, it is not disputed that the event would have been an evangelical outreach event for up to twelve thousand people,” McCormick wrote. “That is not to say that his opinions are not offensive to some whether in Glasgow or elsewhere. However, the pursuer’s right to engage a speaker at the evangelical event — in furtherance of a religious or philosophical belief — is protected by law.”
According to the Christian Post, Graham said he is “grateful to God for this decision,” viewing the ruling as “a clear victory for freedom of speech and religion in the UK.”
Graham further stated the lawsuit was not about receiving a settlement but “about the preservation of religious freedom in the UK.”
“I want to thank Sheriff John McCormick for upholding the law and affirming that Christians must be treated fairly and equally,” Graham went on to say. “This ruling will be a great encouragement for Christians and people of all faiths across the UK and many other parts of the world.”
A spokesperson for SEC expressed to the BBC that they were disappointed by the ruling and that they are “currently reviewing the extensive documentation to determine whether any further action is required.”
Graham’s events had been set for May through October of 2020. Ironically, the events likely would have been indefinitely postponed anyway due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
The UK leg of the “God Loves You” tour was rescheduled and took place earlier this year.
This article was originally published by ChurchLeaders.com.