Type to search

Culture Ministry News Pro-Life

NJ Pregnancy Center Appeals to Supreme Court

NJ attorney general issued subpoena asking for donor information.

Avatar photo

First Choice Women’s Resource Centers, a group of pregnancy resource centers in New Jersey, has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to consider its case about the state asking it to disclose information about its donors.

Photo via ADF

In November 2023, New Jersey Attorney General Matthew Platkin demanded that First Choice turn over many documents, including information it provides to clients, statements about abortion pill reversal, documents about personnel and outside organizations with which it works, and donor information.

Platkin has openly expressed his hostility toward pregnancy centers. “He issued a consumer alert—drafted with the help of Planned Parenthood—complaining that such centers do not provide or refer for abortion. He also signed an open letter pledging to take legal action against pregnancy centers,” the brief to the Supreme Court reads.

Alliance Defending Freedom, on behalf of First Choice, challenged the attorney general’s subpoena based on the First and Fourteenth Amendments to the U.S. Constitution. The subpoena chills the right to freedom of association and freedom of speech, the brief argues.

The federal courts dismissed the case, claiming it was not ripe until the state court enforced the subpoena. The attorney general then filed an enforcement action in state court.

The state court granted enforcement of the subpoena, but it declined to decide the federal constitutional claims raised by First Choice, finding them “premature.”

First Choice filed an appeal, but meanwhile, it began producing some documents requested by the subpoena.

Access to MinistryWatch content is free.  However, we hope you will support our work with your prayers and financial gifts.  To make a donation, click here.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit sent the case back to the federal district court, now stating that First Choice’s claims were ripe. However, in taking up the motion for an injunction, the federal district court again declared the claims would not be ripe until the state court “require[s] the subpoena recipient to respond to the subpoena under threat of contempt.”

Again First Choice appealed to the Third Circuit. The majority there said the case was still not ripe because the pregnancy center could still assert its constitutional claims in the state court.

“The lower courts have wrongly held that First Choice is relegated to state court to present its constitutional claims. That is inconsistent with civil rights law and with the First Amendment,” ADF Senior Counsel Erin Hawley said in a press statement.

There is a split in the U.S. Courts of Appeal about how to handle this question of whether a state investigatory claim has to be adjudicated in state court before a federal court has jurisdiction. “The Third and Fifth Circuits impose this state-court litigation requirement, but the Ninth Circuit holds that a concrete injury caused by the challenged subpoena satisfies Article III,” the brief states.

TO OUR READERS: Do you have a story idea, or do you want to give us feedback about this or any other story? Please email us: [email protected]

Tags:
Avatar photo
Kim Roberts

Kim Roberts is an award-winning freelance writer who holds a Juris Doctorate with high honors from Baylor University and an undergraduate degree in government with highest honors from Angelo State University. She has three young adult children who were home schooled and is happily married to her husband of 30 years.

    1

New? Start Here

We are an independent resource, keeping our ministries transparent, accountable, and credible.

Financial Data on 1,800+ Ministries

See where your giving goes with our database and ministry rankings.

News: Fair & Accurate Reporting

We never accept advertising dollars or ministry sponsorship.

Stewardship
Assessment

Is your charitable giving achieving maximum impact?

Keep MinistryWatch Free

We are 100% donor-supported and take $0 from advertisers or the ministries we cover.

Editor’s Pick

What’s top of mind at the MinistryWatch team.

Stay Informed! Our Newsletter

The Insight Every Donor Needs

Get investigative journalism first: original reporting on the Christian ministry world, delivered straight to your inbox.

Discover Shining Lights: ministries doing faithful, effective work worth supporting.

See the newest MinistryWatch 1000 ratings: updates on Transparency Grades and financial efficiency scores as they’re released.

Give smarter, not just more: practical insight to help you steward your giving with confidence.

Discover events near you: Join Warren and the MinistryWatch team for events when we come to your area.

Join 100,000+ Readers

Financial Database: Know Before You Give

For 25 years, we’ve tracked the financial data behind 1,800 of the largest Christian ministries. Search by sector, compare ratings, and see the numbers behind the names. Free, with no login required to browse.

1,800+

ministries tracked

25

years of financial data

100%

free, always.

The MinistryWatch Podcast

Hosted by Warren Cole Smith. 600+ episodes of news, interviews, and commentary on the Christian ministry world.

Ep. 664: How To Confront Well: A Conversation with Bill Newton

Christians are often told to love their neighbors, turn the other cheek, and avoid unnecessary conflict. But what happens when love requires confrontation? When silence becomes complicity? And when speaking the truth means risking relationships, reputations, or even our standing in the Christian community? Those

Stay Connected, Join Us On