Type to search

#ChurchToo Church

Lawsuit to Continue Against Gateway for Misappropriating Tithes 

Gateway asked the court to dismiss the case on First Amendment grounds.

Avatar photo

A federal lawsuit filed against Gateway Church alleging fraud, misrepresentation, and breach of contract arising out of their alleged misappropriation of church members’ tithe funds can continue.

The Southlake location is the main campus location of Gateway Church / Photo courtesy of Gateway’s website

U.S. District Judge Amos Mazzant denied a motion to dismiss by the church and its former pastor Robert Morris on September 17 and granted the plaintiffs an opportunity to amend their pleadings.

Gateway Church has been in the news after Cindy Clemishire publicly accused its founding pastor Robert Morris of sexually abusing her in the 1980s, starting when she was 12 years old. Morris resigned in June 2024 and is now facing criminal charges in Oklahoma.

Plaintiffs Katherine and Gary Leach and Mark and Terri Browder brought a class action last October alleging that Gateway Church falsely represented that it gave 15% of all donations to global missions and Jewish ministry partners. They claim Gateway “guaranteed Plaintiffs a refund of their donated funds if Plaintiffs were dissatisfied with Gateway’s use of such funds.”

The plaintiffs were church members who had faithfully contributed to Gateway Church for years.

They simply wanted the church to “open its books, answer questions, and demonstrate that the church is a good steward of these funds,” Micah Dortch, attorney for the plaintiffs, said in a press statement.

Access to MinistryWatch content is free. However, we hope you will support our work with your prayers and financial gifts. To make a donation, click here.

While Morris claimed that Gateway had sent more than $25 million overseas, a certified public accountant (CPA), who was also an executive pastor, allegedly said he never witnessed more than $3 million annually in global missions contributions.

According to the lawsuit, the CPA also noted financial irregularities in the Gateway Global Ministries fund balance and brought those to the attention of Gateway leaders.

The CPA claimed he told Executive Pastor Tom Lane that he could not be part of financial irregularities and would resign if they were not addressed. Lane said he spoke with Morris, and they accepted his resignation.

“Rather than practice transparent stewardship with one of its key pastors, who was hired to lead the directly relevant global ministry, the Church ignored and buried his concerns,” the lawsuit alleges.

Gateway argued the federal lawsuit should be dismissed based on the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine because the claims “will require the Court to impermissibly entangle itself in questions of religious doctrine and internal church administration.”

First Liberty Institute, a public interest law firm defending religious liberty, wrote in its “friend of the court” brief about the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine, “[A]djudicating these claims would require the Court to answer several religious questions, including (1) interpreting the meaning of a pastor’s sermon; (2) defining the meaning of “tithe”; and (3) conducting fact-finding into the religious purposes of every donation Gateway received or made during the relevant time period. All of these inquiries are constitutionally impermissible.”

At this point in the case, Mazzant said he cannot find that the alleged improper expenditure of tithing funds is a purely ecclesiastical question, writing, “The Court acknowledges the act of tithing is a religious act, but Plaintiffs do not dispute their tithing; rather, Plaintiffs allege their tithes were fraudulently allocated and Defendants misrepresented critical facts to Plaintiffs before tithing.”

He said the defendants can again assert this as a basis to dismiss the claim once the record in the case is better developed.

The court also allowed the plaintiffs 14 days to file an amended complaint to replead any causes of action and to add claims and parties to the lawsuit.

Our full coverage of Gateway Church and Robert Morris can be found here.

EDITOR’S NOTE:  Why does MinistryWatch report on financial fraud in the church?  We report on them because one in three churches will be victimized, according to the Center for the Study of Global Christianity. We also report on them because these crimes have real victims and cost taxpayers and other stakeholders billions of dollars every year.  Even small crimes in small churches have huge consequences.  We also report on them to remind our readers that they do not have to be victims. There are steps you can take to prevent financial waste, fraud, and abuse in your church or ministry.  To find out more, click here.

TO OUR READERS: The mission of MinistryWatch is to help Christian donors become more faithful stewards of the resources God has entrusted to them. Do you know of a story that will help us fulfill our mission, or do you want to give us feedback about this or any other story? If so, please email us at [email protected].

Tags:
Avatar photo
Kim Roberts

Kim Roberts is an award-winning freelance writer who holds a Juris Doctorate with high honors from Baylor University and an undergraduate degree in government with highest honors from Angelo State University. She has three young adult children who were home schooled and is happily married to her husband of 30 years.

    1

New? Start Here

We are an independent resource, keeping our ministries transparent, accountable, and credible.

Financial Data on 1,800+ Ministries

See where your giving goes with our database and ministry rankings.

News: Fair & Accurate Reporting

We never accept advertising dollars or ministry sponsorship.

Stewardship
Assessment

Is your charitable giving achieving maximum impact?

Keep MinistryWatch Free

We are 100% donor-supported and take $0 from advertisers or the ministries we cover.

Editor’s Pick

What’s top of mind at the MinistryWatch team.

Stay Informed! Our Newsletter

The Insight Every Donor Needs

Get investigative journalism first: original reporting on the Christian ministry world, delivered straight to your inbox.

Discover Shining Lights: ministries doing faithful, effective work worth supporting.

See the newest MinistryWatch 1000 ratings: updates on Transparency Grades and financial efficiency scores as they’re released.

Give smarter, not just more: practical insight to help you steward your giving with confidence.

Discover events near you: Join Warren and the MinistryWatch team for events when we come to your area.

Join 100,000+ Readers

Financial Database: Know Before You Give

For 25 years, we’ve tracked the financial data behind 1,800 of the largest Christian ministries. Search by sector, compare ratings, and see the numbers behind the names. Free, with no login required to browse.

1,800+

ministries tracked

25

years of financial data

100%

free, always.

The MinistryWatch Podcast

Hosted by Warren Cole Smith. 600+ episodes of news, interviews, and commentary on the Christian ministry world.

Ep. 664: How To Confront Well: A Conversation with Bill Newton

Christians are often told to love their neighbors, turn the other cheek, and avoid unnecessary conflict. But what happens when love requires confrontation? When silence becomes complicity? And when speaking the truth means risking relationships, reputations, or even our standing in the Christian community? Those

Stay Connected, Join Us On

0 Shares
Tweet
Share
Pin
Share