Type to search

Church Featured

Highland Park Church Sues UMC Over Rights to its Name

The name dispute escalates an ongoing legal battle between the Dallas congregation and the denomination.

(RNS) — After voting to cut ties with the United Methodist Church, Highland Park Methodist filed a temporary restraining order last week to stop the denomination from using the Highland Park name.

Highland Park United Methodist Church in Dallas. (Courtesy photo)

Members of the Dallas church, the largest in the UMC fold, voted last month to leave the denomination — a symbolic move since there is no provision for leaving in the UMC rulebook.

Bishop Ruben Saenz Jr., of the Horizon Texas Conference, then decided that those who voted to remain United Methodist — about 10% of the nearly 5,000 members who voted — should be allowed to continue to worship as a church with the name Highland Park United Methodist Church. He also provided a new pastor to lead them.

In court documents filed Nov. 10, the exiting church said another congregation with the name “Highland Park United Methodist” amounts to trademark infringement. The church that voted to leave wants to keep its name — Highland Park Methodist Church, minus the “United” — and prevent others from using it.

The fight against the new name is yet another escalation in the dispute between the 110-year-old congregation and the denomination.

A massive gothic edifice, Highland Park includes many prominent Dallas business and civic leaders, including former President George W. Bush. Bush and his wife, Laura, who voted to leave the UMC, The New York Times reported.

“We welcome the Conference’s new congregation to choose from any of the nearly infinite names that use ‘United Methodist Church’ but do not cause confusion and discord by appropriating our legally protected corporate name, trademarks, legal identity, and goodwill,” the church explained on its website.

The dispute began in August, when the bishop sued Highland Park over changes the church made to its governing documents that attempted to chart a more independent course. Those changes removed “United” from the church’s legal name and gave the church council authority to make broad decisions typically made by the denomination.

Access to MinistryWatch content is free. However, we hope you will support our work with your prayers and financial gifts. To make a donation, click here.

After the church voted to leave the fold, Saenz wrote to church members who voted to remain in the denomination to say he had not abandoned them and wanted to provide them a place to continue worshipping. Those members are now meeting at Southern Methodist University’s Prothro Great Hall.

“As United Methodists, we respect the right of every individual and family to make personal decisions about their faith and where they worship,” the Horizon Texas Conference said in a statement. “At the same time, Highland Park United Methodist Church continues today as a congregation of The United Methodist Church under the leadership of the Rev. Andy Lewis, appointed by Bishop Ruben Saenz Jr.”

The original lawsuit over church governance and property remains ongoing.

TO OUR READERS: The mission of MinistryWatch is to help Christian donors become more faithful stewards of the resources God has entrusted to them. Do you know of a story that will help us fulfill our mission, or do you want to give us feedback about this or any other story? If so, please email us at [email protected].

Tags:
Yonat Shimron

Yonat Shimron is a North Carolina-based reporter who has written about religion for more than 17 years. She is a national reporter and senior editor for Religion News Service.

    1

New? Start Here

We are an independent resource, keeping our ministries transparent, accountable, and credible.

Financial Data on 1,800+ Ministries

See where your giving goes with our database and ministry rankings.

News: Fair & Accurate Reporting

We never accept advertising dollars or ministry sponsorship.

Stewardship
Assessment

Is your charitable giving achieving maximum impact?

Keep MinistryWatch Free

We are 100% donor-supported and take $0 from advertisers or the ministries we cover.

Editor’s Pick

What’s top of mind at the MinistryWatch team.

Stay Informed! Our Newsletter

The Insight Every Donor Needs

Get investigative journalism first: original reporting on the Christian ministry world, delivered straight to your inbox.

Discover Shining Lights: ministries doing faithful, effective work worth supporting.

See the newest MinistryWatch 1000 ratings: updates on Transparency Grades and financial efficiency scores as they’re released.

Give smarter, not just more: practical insight to help you steward your giving with confidence.

Discover events near you: Join Warren and the MinistryWatch team for events when we come to your area.

Join 100,000+ Readers

Financial Database: Know Before You Give

For 25 years, we’ve tracked the financial data behind 1,800 of the largest Christian ministries. Search by sector, compare ratings, and see the numbers behind the names. Free, with no login required to browse.

1,800+

ministries tracked

25

years of financial data

100%

free, always.

The MinistryWatch Podcast

Hosted by Warren Cole Smith. 600+ episodes of news, interviews, and commentary on the Christian ministry world.

Ep. 664: How To Confront Well: A Conversation with Bill Newton

Christians are often told to love their neighbors, turn the other cheek, and avoid unnecessary conflict. But what happens when love requires confrontation? When silence becomes complicity? And when speaking the truth means risking relationships, reputations, or even our standing in the Christian community? Those

Stay Connected, Join Us On